#60995 - BYU men and relationships

[Katya]

http://theboard.byu.edu/questions/60995/

I think we can call this question the poster child for the phenomenon of "funny answers get more thumbs up than good answers." (I'm part of the problem, since I voted up CK's answer, as well. But then I realized what I'd done and thumbed up Mico's answer, as well.)

[Tao]

Must say I was slightly amused by the question itself, all things considered.

[Marduk]

Yes, I found most amusing the term "been flirted." Apparently it is a passive thing, and she had no involvement in it whatsoever. Damn these drive-by flirtings.

[Craig Jessop]

Yes, I found most amusing the term "been flirted." Apparently it is a passive thing, and she had no involvement in it whatsoever. Damn these drive-by flirtings.

*LIKE*

[Laser Jock]

http://theboard.byu.edu/questions/60995/

I think we can call this question the poster child for the phenomenon of "funny answers get more thumbs up than good answers." (I'm part of the problem, since I voted up CK's answer, as well. But then I realized what I'd done and thumbed up Mico's answer, as well.)

Yeah, I think the thumbs-up thing is pretty clearly equivalent to Facebook's "like" button as far as what people use it to convey. (Which isn't a bad thing, mind you.) It's not exactly what I think we had in mind, but it's a valid thing to measure too.

[Commander Keen]

Well Katya, it's not like I just wrote that answer so I could get my anonymous glory kicks. I only wrote it to highlight how dumb I thought the question really was.

But I thought your system of administering justice was humorous. Maybe I'll start thumbs-upping every answer just to mess with the system (smiley to indicate the tone of this response).

[Katya]

Well Katya, it's not like I just wrote that answer so I could get my anonymous glory kicks. I only wrote it to highlight how dumb I thought the question really was.

Nah, I thought it was a great answer. But LJ and I have talked before about how the thumbs system favors some kinds of answering greatness over others. (I guess I could amend my original post to say that "funny answers get more thumbs than thoughtful but serious answers," or something along those lines.)

[thebigcheese]

http://theboard.byu.edu/questions/60995/

I think we can call this question the poster child for the phenomenon of "funny answers get more thumbs up than good answers." (I'm part of the problem, since I voted up CK's answer, as well. But then I realized what I'd done and thumbed up Mico's answer, as well.)

Yeah, I think the thumbs-up thing is pretty clearly equivalent to Facebook's "like" button as far as what people use it to convey. (Which isn't a bad thing, mind you.) It's not exactly what I think we had in mind, but it's a valid thing to measure too.

Yeah. I like the "Editor's Choice" designation for legitimately good answers...thumbs up is basically just for fun.

[Katya]

http://theboard.byu.edu/questions/60995/

I think we can call this question the poster child for the phenomenon of "funny answers get more thumbs up than good answers." (I'm part of the problem, since I voted up CK's answer, as well. But then I realized what I'd done and thumbed up Mico's answer, as well.)

Yeah, I think the thumbs-up thing is pretty clearly equivalent to Facebook's "like" button as far as what people use it to convey. (Which isn't a bad thing, mind you.) It's not exactly what I think we had in mind, but it's a valid thing to measure too.

Yeah. I like the "Editor's Choice" designation for legitimately good answers...thumbs up is basically just for fun.

Right, but "Editor's Choice" is binary, while the thumbs are gradable. Both types of categories have benefits and drawbacks.