return of a legally dead person (question from 2006)

What do you think about the latest hot topic from the 100 Hour Board? Speak your piece here!

Moderator: Marduk

Post Reply
Cindy
Posts: 184
Joined: Mon Nov 19, 2007 10:09 pm

return of a legally dead person (question from 2006)

Post by Cindy »

A while back, I asked this question about what happens when someone who's been declared dead turns up again and wants his stuff back. The answer satisfied my curiosity, and I haven't really thought about it since then.

But now my favorite legal humor blog reports that this issue came up recently in a case in Ohio. There, the court decided that the guy couldn't have his standing as a living person reinstated, since he hadn't challenged the death decree within the statutory three-year time limit.

That makes questions about his estate distribution much simpler, but it does raise some interesting questions about whether, for instance, he can get a driver's license, commit a crime, or be required to pay taxes as a legally deceased person. (Part of the problem arises from the fact that Ohio law states that the death is presumed to have occurred on the date of the death decree "for all purposes under the law of this state," not just for probate purposes.)

It's an interesting case. It's also interesting that this didn't come up because of any kind of Castaway type situation. Rather, the guy apparently just left and didn't bother telling people about it:
Miller had been "last reported in Arcadia" in 1986. He testified Monday that he had lost his job, decided to look elsewhere for work, and then it just "kind of went further than I ever expected it to." (I.e., Florida.) After he'd been missing for eight years, his ex-wife asked for the death decree so their children could get Social Security death benefits, and Judge Davis agreed. According to the report, Miller returned to Ohio in 2005, whereupon his parents informed him that he was dead. He's apparently been okay with that for some time, but told the court that he would like to be alive again now so he can get his Social Security card and driver's license back.
User avatar
vorpal blade
Posts: 1750
Joined: Tue Jul 01, 2008 5:08 pm
Location: New Jersey

Re: return of a legally dead person (question from 2006)

Post by vorpal blade »

That's really interesting, Cindy. It is not that he has no identity. He has a name, a birth certificate, and other legal proof of who he is. He is just dead, however. If he committed a crime they could book him as some John Doe, but then when he proved who he was they would have the awkward situation of explaining how a dead man committed the crime. An illegal alien could get a driver license before this guy. And every time he voted it would automatically be voter fraud. If he ran for president I wonder if anyone would check to see if he were legally dead. But then, is there a requirement that you have to be alive?
User avatar
Dragon Lady
Posts: 2332
Joined: Tue Aug 21, 2007 12:07 pm
Location: Riverton, UT

Re: return of a legally dead person (question from 2006)

Post by Dragon Lady »

As much as I hate the whole zombie fad… could this be the realistic form of the beginning of the zombie apocalypse?
User avatar
Marduk
Most Attractive Mod
Posts: 2995
Joined: Thu Nov 05, 2009 4:15 pm
Location: Orem, UT
Contact:

Re: return of a legally dead person (question from 2006)

Post by Marduk »

I'm just sick of all these illegal dead immigrants coming and taking jobs from hardworking, living, Americans.
Deus ab veritas
User avatar
Dragon Lady
Posts: 2332
Joined: Tue Aug 21, 2007 12:07 pm
Location: Riverton, UT

Re: return of a legally dead person (question from 2006)

Post by Dragon Lady »

Marduk wrote:I'm just sick of all these illegal dead immigrants coming and taking jobs from hardworking, living, Americans.
[snort]
Post Reply